Crime Explorer LogoCrime Explorer

Shelter Island Town, NY Crime Statistics

Crime Overview

The Shelter Island Town Police Department serves the city of Shelter Island Town, NY in Suffolk County. Over the past five years (2019-2024), the city recorded 18 violent crimes and 41 property crimes. The average violent crime rate stands at 30.4 per 100k residents, which is 71.4% below the national average. Property crime averages 91.3 per 100k, 44.2% below the national average. The most common offense was Property Crime, while Violent Crime had the lowest rate. Data is sourced from the FBI Crime Data Explorer and reflects totals from the most recent five-year period.

Violent Crimes

Violent Crime

Grade A
Annual Rate30.4 per 100k residents
National Avg: 106.2 per 100k
Total Incidents18 (2019-2023)

Aggravated Assault

Grade D

Not enough data to calculate a meaningful rate.

Property Crimes

Property Crime

Grade A
Annual Rate91.3 per 100k residents
National Avg: 163.6 per 100k
Total Incidents41 (2019-2023)

Burglary

Grade D

Not enough data to calculate a meaningful rate.

Larceny

Grade A
Annual Rate60.9 per 100k residents
National Avg: 116.4 per 100k
Total Incidents32 (2019-2023)

Crime Summary

Crime TypeAnnual Rate (per 100k residents)GradeTotal Incidents (2019-2023)National Avg% Difference
Violent Crime30.4A18106.2-71.4%
Property Crime91.3A41163.6-44.2%
Aggravated Assault30.4D122.3+36.7%
Burglary30.4D824.0+26.6%
Larceny60.9A32116.4-47.7%

Crime Trends

Nearby Cities

City Distance Violent Crime Property Crime Comparison
Sag Harbor Village 0 miles
N/A 0.0
A 35.7
Violent: N/A
Property: 60.9% lower
Southampton Village 0 miles
A 43.0
C 150.4
Violent: 41.3% higher
Property: 64.8% higher
Ocean Beach Village 0 miles
N/A 0.0
N/A 0.0
Violent: N/A
Property: N/A
Quogue Village 0 miles
N/A 0.0
A 58.8
Violent: N/A
Property: 35.6% lower
Nissequogue Village 0 miles
N/A 0.0
N/A 0.0
Violent: N/A
Property: N/A